


A new analytical report, based on monitoring conducted by the Public Foundation Civics, examines the legal regulation of Kyrgyzstan’s Bar Association. The report assesses the institutional and functional independence of the Bar and examines the alignment of national legislation with international standards governing the legal profession. This study is part of a a series of analytical reports prepared by members of the Akyikat Karegi Civil Society Network, using a comprehensive methodology developed by international and national experts. It is published under a project implemented by International Partnership for Human Rights (IPHR) and Lawyers for Human Rights (LHR) with support from the EU.
Key Findings
Key findings of the report include:
● The Bar of the Kyrgyz Republic is intended to be an autonomous and self-governing body. However, the involvement of the Ministry of Justice in its elections and activities undermines this independence. It is crucial to reduce state interference and ensure greater autonomy for the Bar. This should include the exclusion of state officials from the Bar’s executive bodies, such as its qualification and ethics commissions. In addition, licensing and certification processes should be reviewed to ensure they are fair, impartial, and non-discriminatory, and clearer definitions and classifications of disciplinary offences should be established.
● Elections to the governing bodies of the Bar held in January 2024 demonstrated shortcomings in ensuring fair and transparent elections. These included limited opportunities for campaigning and difficulties for candidates from smaller regions to gain representation. These shortcomings need to be addressed
● To enhance transparency and accountability, the Bar should establish standardised reporting requirements for its governing bodies and ensure that reports are published. Improved internal structures will help uphold core principles, thereby enhancing public trust and the standing of the legal profession.
● Continuing professional development is vital. The Bar should continue to improve its educational programmes, expand training centres, and introduce modern teaching methods. It should review professional quality standards to ensure they align with international standards, and apply to all lawyers, and monitor their implementation in practice.
Based on the indicators established by the Methodology for Monitoring the Criminal Justice Sector, the overall assessment of the Bar amounted to 9 out of 17 possible scores.
Recommendations have been developed for each key indicator to align national legislation with international standards.
The full report can be downloaded below (in Russian, Kyrgyz), with a summary available in English.
***The analytical report has been prepared with financial support from the European Union. The contents are the sole responsibility of the organisations issuing it and do not necessarily reflect the views of the European Union.***

