Quick search
Advanced search
Reset all
All news
Kazakhstan: Key issues and recommendations for UPR
Human Rights Council meeting venue - IPHR photo
Kazakhstan: Key issues and recommendations for UPR
Human Rights Council meeting venue - IPHR photo

Kazakhstan’s human rights record will be examined under the Universal Periodic Review (UPR), held under the auspices of the UN Human Rights Council, on 23 January 2025. International Partnership for Human Rights (IPHR) and Kazakhstan International Bureau for Human Rights and Rule of Law (KIBHR) have prepared a joint report for the review, highlighting key issues regarding the protection of civic space and the freedoms of expression, association and assembly.

The report, which is based on the organisations’ ongoing cooperation on documenting developments in these areas, covers the following key issues and recommendations:

Lack of accountability for human rights violations perpetrated during January 2022 events

During the January 2022 events in Kazakhstan, peaceful protests for social and political change evolved into unrest and clashes between security forces and people in the crowd, leaving over 230 people dead and thousands injured. The authorities have rejected calls for an international investigation into these events, while failing to adequately address allegations of excessive force, torture, and other abuses by law enforcement and security forces. Monitoring by human rights groups revealed that security forces often used indiscriminate and unwarranted force, and hundreds of complaints of torture of detained protesters were filed, with six confirmed deaths in custody.

While more than 30 officials have been prosecuted and convicted for abuses, the number remains low compared to the scale of violations, and proceedings have often been marred by fair trial concerns and lenient penalties. Many investigations were prematurely closed. It is of further concern that activists have faced questionable prosecution for their alleged role in the January events. In addition, some protesters killed during the events have been posthumously convicted of offenses without clarity on the circumstances of their deaths.

Recommendations

The Kazakhstani authorities should:

  • Allow an independent international inquiry to clarify the January 2022 events, and determine the roles and responsibility of different actors.
  • Impartially, thoroughly and effectively investigate all allegations of excessive force, torture, and other abuses, reopen prematurely closed cases, and ensure those responsible face fair trials with appropriate penalties.
  • Drop charges against individuals prosecuted for peacefully protesting during the January 2022 events and ensure proceedings meet international standards.

Ongoing violations of the freedom of assembly

Despite being promoted as progressive, a 2020 law on assemblies falls short of international standards by de-facto requiring advance permission for protests, restricting assemblies to designated venues, and failing to protect spontaneous protests. Authorities have selectively denied permission for protests, dispersed unsanctioned assemblies, and detained participants, including those engaging in individual pickets or informal gatherings without a protest purpose. Activists have also been detained preventively ahead of planned protests, or weeks after protests, and penalised for social media announcements of protests. Internet access has often been arbitrarily restricted during protests, hindering communication and coverage.

Using these kinds of tactics, authorities have obstructed assemblies on issues such as justice for victims of the January 2022 events, opposition to Russia’s war on Ukraine, women’s rights, challenging government plans to build a nuclear power plant, electoral fairness, democratic reforms, the release of political prisoners.

Recommendations

The Kazakhstani authorities should:

  • Align the law on assemblies with international standards, ensuring a simple notification procedure, clear definitions, and protection for spontaneous protests.
  • Allow peaceful protests to take place without interference and cease detaining and penalising participants before, during and after unsanctioned peaceful assemblies.
  • Refrain from arbitrary internet restrictions during peaceful protests.

Violations of the freedom of association

Despite the president’s political modernisation drive, no genuine opposition party has been registered in Kazakhstan, and opposition groups like Alga Kazakhstan! and the Democratic Party have faced ongoing harassment, surveillance, and politically motivated prosecutions. Authorities have also cracked down on supporters of the banned non-violent opposition movements Democratic Choice of Kazakhstan and Koshe Partiyasy, prosecuting peaceful activities as “extremism.”

Meanwhile, civil society organisations receiving foreign funding are subjected to a discriminatory reporting scheme and have faced pressure, including threats of suspension for alleged technical reporting violations. The publication of a list of foreign-funded entities, including prominent human rights organisations, in autumn 2023 further stigmatised such groups. Concerns persist about potential new measures against foreign-funded groups, especially following Kazakhstan’s increased cooperation with Russia on countering “foreign agents.”

Authorities have also restricted the freedom of association of LGBT groups. For example, the Feminita movement has faced repeated denials of registration, as well as other intimidation and harassment, including public calls for it to be banned as ‘’extremist’’.

Recommendations

The Kazakhstani authorities should:

  • Allow opposition parties to register and operate freely, and stop intimidating and harassing opposition activists for their peaceful engagement.
  • End discriminatory measures against foreign-funded civil society organisations, including by abolishing the public list of such groups and the separate reporting scheme for them.
  • Ensure LGBT groups can freely associate, investigate any incidents of harassment against them, and hold perpetrators accountable.

Violations of the freedom of expression

Kazakhstan’s new media law, which took effect in August 2024, has raised significant concerns among media experts and human rights defenders despite some positive features such as a ban on censorship and quicker state responses to media inquiries. In particular, vague restrictions on media content, insufficient safeguards against arbitrary actions, and problematic new registration and accreditation requirements have been criticised for falling short of international standards.

In the context of enhanced efforts to protect ‘’traditional’’ values, a public petition to ban ‘’LGBT propaganda’’ in summer 2024 prompted a government-ordered study on the alleged influence of LGBT materials on children, raising concerns that new restrictive legislation might follow in this area. Existing legislation banning the spread of “false” information has been increasingly misused to stifle dissent, with media, journalists and others targeted for legitimate free speech.

Independent media and journalists have also been subjected to on- and offline attacks, with perpetrators often remaining unpunished. The assassination of an exile-based journalist in summer 2024 further highlighted the risks faced by those reporting on sensitive issues in Kazakhstan.

Recommendations

The Kazakhstani authorities should:

  • Ensure the new media law aligns with international standards and does not result in violations of media freedom.
  • Refrain from measures unduly restricting free expression under the guise of protecting ‘’traditional’’ values or combatting disinformation.
  • Investigate and address all cases of media and journalist harassment, holding perpetrators accountable.

Persecution of activists, journalists, and bloggers

Civil society activists, opposition supporters, human rights defenders, journalists, and bloggers who are critical of the authorities face ongoing intimidation and harassment, ranging from online threats to arrest and prosecution on politically motivated charges. Those targeted for prosecution have often been charged under broadly worded Criminal Code provisions, such as those prohibiting the spread of ‘’false’’ information, ‘’incitement’’ to discord, or involvement in ‘’extremism’’. The trials against activists have been characterised by due process and fair trial violations, with lengthy prison sentences issued despite the lack of credible evidence. In some cases, extradition requests have been issued for critical voices based abroad. There have also been reports of ill-treatment and pressure against activists in detention. This pattern of targeting individuals for their legitimate exercise of the freedoms of expression, association and assembly is highly worrying.

Recommendations

The Kazakhstani authorities should:

  • Cease arresting and prosecuting activists, journalists, and human rights defenders for exercising their fundamental freedoms and release those currently imprisoned on such charges.
  • Stop misusing Criminal Code provisions related to “false information,” “inciting discord”, and “extremism” to penalise activists for peaceful activities, and align these provisions with international standards.
  • Investigate allegations of mistreatment of activists in detention and hold those responsible accountable.

The full IPHR-KIBHR report (updated as of December 2024), as well as the summary can be downloaded below.

***

The IPHR-KIBHR report was submitted as a contribution to the compilation of civil society concerns, prepared by the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) as a key source of information for the UPR. It has also been shared with UN member states and other relevant stakeholders.

The UPR will review Kazakhstan’s human rights record based on information from the government, UN human rights bodies, and civil society organisations. It will involve an exchange between Kazakhstan and member and observer states of the Human Rights Council, concluding with an outcome report containing recommendations for Kazakhstan.

Kazakhstan: the latest news

More news
Central Asia: Entrenched Restrictions and Emerging Threats to Civic Space – Joint Statement

Central Asia: Entrenched Restrictions and Emerging Threats to Civic Space – Joint Statement

See 2 attached documents
Kazakhstan: Stop the Imminent Extradition of Yulia Emelyanova and Mansur Movlaev to Russia

Kazakhstan: Stop the Imminent Extradition of Yulia Emelyanova and Mansur Movlaev to Russia

Joint Statement - Stop the Imminent Extradition of Yulia Emelyanova and Mansur Movlaev to Russia
Kazakhstan: EU-funded Rule of Law Academy Builds Civil Society Expertise

Kazakhstan: EU-funded Rule of Law Academy Builds Civil Society Expertise

See 3 attached documents

Subscribe to our updates

Please select the topic(s) on which you wish to receive news/updates from us
Type of information you wish to receive
Copied!
IPHR
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.